WKY gas pipeline agency is spending state dollars on engineering, litigation, lobbying 

Posted
A shaded line shows the pipeline route across Davenport's property.

An image showing the proposed natural gas pipeline route through Greg Davenport's family farm in Christian County. Much of the proposed route follows along Interstate 24 in Western Kentucky. (Screenshot/Court exhibit)

Critics of a public agency in Western Kentucky that’s trying to build a 53-mile natural gas pipeline have scrutinized the project as the agency has sued landowners, wielding eminent domain, in an effort to secure remaining easements needed to build the pipeline. 

Among the questions that these critics, including landowners being sued, have: how the agency is spending a $30 million appropriation from the Kentucky legislature in 2022 to jumpstart the agency’s efforts, the sole funding source that the Todd County-based Pennyrile Regional Energy Agency has relied on.

Elected officials in the two small Todd County cities of Guthrie and Trenton, with a combined population of fewer than 2,000, formed the public agency in 2019 as the Todd County Natural Gas District. In 2021, the agency rebranded and proposed to build the regional pipeline as part of efforts to expand the region’s natural gas supply as an economic development boon to supply customers including the Fort Campbell military installation and to an existing Novelis aluminum recycling facility for a potential expansion.

But Milton Furman Cook, a Lyon County farmer among the landowners currently being sued, told the Lantern he doesn’t believe the other Western Kentucky counties along the pipeline route — Lyon, Trigg, Caldwell, Christian — will benefit in the same way Todd County will. 

“My tax dollars are being used to condemn my property on a project that will have no benefit for the people in my community,” Cook said. “This would be one thing if this was an interstate that was going to help a lot of people. This is a small group of people that it’s going to benefit.”

A Kentucky Lantern analysis of a recent 12-month window of spending by the agency shows that among the biggest expenditures by the agency are staying local in and around Todd County: payments for engineering fees going toward a local engineering firm in Todd County, and payments to a natural gas consulting firm located in Tennessee right across the Todd County line. The expenditures were obtained through the state’s Open Records Act.

The agency is also spending considerable funding for a Lexington law firm it’s hired to litigate a number of the eminent domain lawsuits it is entangled in with landowners, along with spending to hire a prominent lobbying firm based in Frankfort. 

In a phone interview, Eston Glover, the chair of Pennyrile Regional Energy Agency’s board, refuted the notion that the pipeline was primarily to the benefit of Todd County, saying the entity started in Todd County because local representatives “saw the need” for it. 

“The opportunities to grow from it and to develop a place for our kids to come back and work are going to be occurring in every county,” Glover said. “We want anybody that touches this line to be able to get gas through our pipe to their property.” 

Engineering, litigation and lobbying

Among the top expenditures that PREA reported from October 2025 through September 2026 included: 

  • D2 Energy, a consulting firm for natural gas transportation based just miles away from Guthrie, one of two Todd County cities that created the agency through an interlocal agreement. PREA spent $373,750 for engineering fees toward D2 Energy. 
  • Payments for easements ranging in the tens of thousands of dollars for each payment to landowners. PREA made $253,116.00 in payments for easements over the 12-month time frame. 
  • McGhee Engineering, a Todd County-based engineering firm that has worked on wastewater and drinking water infrastructure projects in Western Kentucky. McGhee Engineering has received $548,900 for engineering fees from PREA.
  • Sturgill, Turner, Barker & Moloney, PLLC, a Lexington-based law firm that PREA has hired as counsel for litigation against landowners over pipeline easements and litigation against Kentucky’s utility regulator. The law firm has received $287,599.39 from PREA. 
  • Commonwealth Alliances LLC, a prominent Frankfort-based lobbying firm whose leader was among the highest paid out of all lobbyists in Frankfort. Commonwealth Alliances LLC received $55,256.00 from PREA. 
  • Tim Thomas, a consultant with Paducah-based Cleaview Consulting LLC, who served previously as the former co-chairman of the Appalachian Regional Commission and was a field representative for U.S. Sen. Mitch McConnell. Thomas’ firm received $56,592.37 from PREA.

Glover said that the agency picked D2 Energy and McGhee Engineering because the firms were “familiar with the area” and the agency. Glover said D2 Energy manages Guthrie’s existing municipal natural gas system, which supplies the existing Novelis plant; McGhee Engineering had also built a gas line extension to the plant. 

“We hired them to do some preliminary engineering. But when we got into the process of going forward, our board decided that they had proven themselves, and we chose them to be our guides for developing this project,” Glover said.

When asked if other firms besides D2 Energy and McGhee Engineering were considered, Brock, the agency’s executive administrator for the agency, said only McGhee Engineering had responded to a request for qualifications sent out by the agency in 2022. 

In a deposition for one of the eminent domain lawsuits in Christian County, McGhee Engineering President Michael McGhee told an attorney representing sued landowners that his firm had not designed a gas pipeline before as large as the 16-inch pipeline that PREA was planning to build. McGhee was also briefly a board member for the local economic development nonprofit Todd County Industrial Foundation, according to the deposition. 

Glover also said the agency hired Tim Thomas for his political connections, along with hiring the prominent lobbying firm Commonwealth Alliances LLC to have a presence in Frankfort. 

“We felt it behooved us to know what was going on legislatively or what was going on around the state that could impact or affect what we’re trying to do with this project,” Glover said. “There’s not many organizations that are trying to do something as broad as we are that do not have some type of lobbyist or information gatherer.” 

The Pennyrile Regional Energy Agency did lobby state lawmakers during the legislative session this year, with Rep. Jason Petrie, R-Elkton, the powerful chair of the Kentucky House Appropriations and Revenue Committee, successfully passing a state law that provided PREA an exception from being regulated by the Kentucky Public Service Commission, the state’s utility regulator. 

When asked about what issues the agency had lobbied in Frankfort, Glover declined to comment because of the agency’s ongoing litigation. 

With that spending, PREA has about $21.8 million in its bank account as of September 2026, according to a bank account balance sheet. The agency has received income in the form of interest payments from its account with the local bank Elkton Bank & Trust Co.; Glover, the agency’s vice chair Gary Traughber and the agency’s attorney Jeff Traughber, who serves as the elected Todd County attorney, also serve on the bank’s board of directors. 

In a deposition earlier in the Christian County court case, Glover told an attorney representing sued landowners that there were no specific state reporting requirements for the $30 million appropriation but that PREA conducted its own audits. He said he updated Petrie, the local state representative, and Gov. Andy Beshear “orally, personally” about the agency. 

A spokesperson for House GOP leadership referred questions about reporting requirements for the funding to the state executive branch. 

In an emailed statement, Scottie Ellis, a spokesperson for Gov. Andy Beshear’s office, said the 2022 law that appropriated the $30 million for the Pennyrile Regional Energy Agency did not include any reporting requirements for the funding. Ellis said the Department for Local Government within the governor’s office does require a completion report for the earmark. 

Glover said his agency has tried to be open to the public, saying their goal is to “put the facts out there” and “not to discredit or to tear down anybody else’s thoughts.” The agency has recently spent funding on advertising. The agency’s website, which previously had no information when the board meets, now features a tentative webpage under construction titled “Board Meetings”. 

“We feel like our records are just exactly the way that they’re supposed to be handled. We have not avoided sharing that information with anybody that wanted to see it, and it’s open to be seen every day,” Glover said. “We’ve learned that there’s so many things that need gas in our general area, and that just reinforces our belief that we’re doing the right thing.”

Courtesy of Kentucky Lantern

Energy, Government, Caldwell, christian county, court cases, critics, eminent domain, gas pipeline, Jason Petrie, lyon county, Pennyrile Regional Energy Agency, scrutiny, spending, taxpayers, todd county, Trigg County