Commentary: Kentucky missed the tax trigger. Here’s how to hit it.

Posted
Mills waits behind a sign during a press conference on housing legislation.

In January, at a pro-housing rally, Sen. Robby Mills, R-Henderson, said bills to tackle the housing shortage should be moving soon in the Kentucky legislature. (Kentucky Lantern photo by Liam Niemeyer)

For the second consecutive year, and the third time in four years, Kentucky has failed to meet the revenue benchmarks required to further cut the state income tax. The shortfall this time wasn’t even close, as General Fund receipts fell short of the threshold needed.

Kentucky’s new tax regime has cut the personal income tax rate from 5 percent to 3.5 percent. In an analysis for the Bluegrass Institute, Rea Hederman Jr. and Sai Martha found that reaching 3 percent would add $810 million in GDP and $370 million in private investment in its first year, and by 2034 would generate $850 million in annual investment and 7,000 new jobs. Our large rainy day fund and the healthy General Fund surplus confirm that Kentucky is not spending recklessly; this means the problem is on the growth side of the ledger.

The commonwealth’s competitors aren’t slowing down. Iowa, Louisiana and Idaho cut individual income tax rates in 2025, and this year Montana did. Both Mississippi and South Carolina have enacted revenue-triggered phase-outs aimed at eliminating the income tax, and Oklahoma has cut its rate with triggers for future cuts.

Senator Chris McDaniel, R-Ryland Heights, chairman of the budget committee, said Kentucky’s miss this year demonstrates the “responsibility” and “reactiveness” of the model. He’s clearly right on the first count, but reactiveness is the wrong posture for a state that has set elimination of its income tax as a long-term goal. Kentucky needs a proactive growth agenda that expands the tax base by making the commonwealth a better place to start a business, build a home, and earn a living.

Three simple reforms, none of which require new spending, would accomplish exactly that.

Cut the red tape

Kentucky’s regulatory code contains more than 127,000 restrictive requirements spread across 6.4 million words. Between 2020 and 2024, the commonwealth’s regulatory burden grew 8.8 percent – double the national median of 4.4 percent. Every one of those restrictions is a barrier between a would-be entrepreneur and satisfied customers.

Patrick McLaughlin of the Hoover Institution, writing for the Bluegrass Institute, documented what happens when states take this problem seriously. When British Columbia cut its regulatory burden by 40 percent, GDP growth surged. Virginia’s 25 percent reduction saves residents an estimated $1.2 billion a year. McLaughlin’s model projects that a 20% cut in Kentucky would leave Kentucky’s economy roughly $14 billion larger by 2037.

Frankfort should begin with a systematic review of the commonwealth’s administrative code by adopting regulatory transparency, identifying rules that are no longer useful and sunsetting them. The Bluegrass Institute’s own research finds that even a 10% reduction in restrictions would raise growth. The General Assembly should give regulatory reform the same priority as income tax reduction – the two are indelibly connected.

Let Kentuckians build

People follow opportunity, and homes are where jobs go to sleep at night. In the Lexington and Bowling Green housing markets, median home prices are near historic highs relative to household income, pricing out workers and families Kentucky needs to attract.

The cause is not a lack of demand, it is a thicket of mostly local regulations – minimum lot sizes, parking mandates, and permitting timelines that stretch months past any reasonable review period. This artificially constrains supply. The Bluegrass Institute’s “Menu of Options for Kentucky Housing Reform” lays out a detailed deregulatory agenda: permitting shot clocks, by-right approval of accessory dwelling units and small multifamily buildings, elimination of arbitrary lot-size minimums and adoption of the “Golden Girls Rule” that lets unrelated adults share a home without local government meddling.

Virginia’s regulatory streamlining, which included simplifying housing rules, is projected to cut roughly $24,000 from the cost of a new home. More homes mean more property tax revenue, more construction jobs, more appliance and furniture sales, and more families putting down roots in Kentucky communities, which all show up in General Fund receipts.

Here in Kentucky, lawmakers failed to deliver on housing affordability when the omnibus housing bill died in the final hours of the 2026 session. This is in spite of the fact that the Kentucky Housing Task Force, co-chaired by Sen. Robby Mills and Rep. Susan Tyler Witten, embraced many Bluegrass Institute recommendations that would expand housing supply at no cost to taxpayers. Too often, the legislature has substituted new government programs like trust funds, loan subsidies, and tax credits for the genuine deregulation that would let the market build. The next session should finish what the task force started.

Open the door

Kentucky requires a government license to work in 132 of 246 occupations tracked by the Archbridge Institute, making us the ninth-most-burdensome licensing regime in the US. The Institute for Justice’s License to Work report finds that Kentucky licenses 38 of 102 lower-income occupations it studied, ranking the commonwealth 13th in licensing burden for the workers who can least afford it.

Research suggests occupational licensing reduces employment by up to 27 % in licensed fields. It is a barrier that keeps people out of the labor force, and is exactly the opposite of what a state trying to grow its tax base should do. Kentucky’s July unemployment rate was 4.7%, above the national average of 4.1%. Neighboring Indiana, which licenses fewer occupations, had an unemployment rate of 3.3%. Correlation is not causation, but the pattern is worth examining.

Every barber, auctioneer, florist and massage therapist who is deterred from working in Kentucky by months of mandatory training, hundreds of dollars in fees and exams that test academic knowledge rather than practical competence is a taxpayer the commonwealth never gains.

The Bluegrass Institute has identified occupational licensing reform as a key move to improve Kentucky’s economic freedom. Kentucky ranks in the bottom half of states on the Fraser Institute’s economic freedom index and is the second-most federally dependent state in the nation. Reducing licensing barriers is one of the fastest ways to change both numbers.

The path forward

Kentucky’s income tax trigger mechanism was designed to ensure that tax cuts are undertaken by a stable government with dependable revenues, not revenues borrowed from future taxpayers. But missing the trigger year after year should not be treated as an acceptable outcome; it should be treated as a policy signal that Kentucky’s private sector is not growing fast enough.

The General Assembly reconvenes in January. Lawmakers who are serious about finishing what HB 8 started should arrive in Frankfort with an agenda that matches their ambition. The path to zero runs through a bigger, freer Kentucky economy.

Courtesy of Kentucky Lantern

Commentary, Economy, Taxes, Bluegrass Institute, general assembly, housing reform, income tax, income tax reduction, licensing, permitting reform